WHEN CAN FINANCIAL PENALTIES BE USED TO DETER NON-COMPLIANCE WITH A MARITAL SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT?
20-2-2066 Holtham v. Lucas, N.J. Super. App. Div. (Ostrer, J.) (18 pp.) Plaintiff appealed from the trial court’s order requiring him to pay defendant $150 per day of plaintiff’s non-compliance with a provision of the parties’ marital settlement agreement that required plaintiff to timely pay off the loan of a vehicle equitably distributed to defendant and tender her title to the car. The MSA also imposed a “per diem penalty of $150” for any breach of the agreement. On appeal, plaintiff argued that the $150 per diem charge constituted an unenforceable contractual penalty. The court agreed that, under traditional contract principles, the per diem charge would constitute an unenforceable penalty as contractual damages should be limited to measurable compensable losses. The court noted that contractual penalties were disfavored to avoid oppression, excessive recovery, and deterrence of economically efficient breach. However, the court affirmed the award entered in favor of defendant and against plaintiff. The court ruled that contractual rules disfavoring penalties did not apply with equal force to marital settlement agreements. The court ruled that marital settlement agreements were intended to foster post-divorce stability and thus enforcement of penalty provisions in MSAs could serve that purpose by deterring non-compliance that was not economically motivated and compensating the non-breaching party for the emotional harm that can result from the breach of an agreement that arises from a personal relationship. Specifically, the court noted the trial court’s finding that plaintiff’s breach was deliberate and lacking any reasoned or economic justification. However, the court noted that although penalty provisions in divorce settlement agreements were enforceable, it held that trial courts retained their inherent authority to ensure that penalty provisions were fair and equitable and to modify such provisions to correct any excessiveness or unfairness.
For those in need of help regarding financial penalties, contact Craig Annin & Baxter to discuss your case or schedule a consultation.
Self-Funded Entities Introduced To The Insurance Fraud Prevention Act
S-3657 is a long sought amendment introduced to the Insurance Fraud Prevention Act. The change in the law will allow the State of New Jersey to use one of its strongest anti-fraud tools to protect the state health benefit plan from fraud. Now the IFPA can be used to...
Workplace Documentation: How an Attorney Can Help
If it is not documented it did not happen. Information management is itself a multi-billion dollar business and the failure to manage information is the downfall of many a business large and small. Individuals and businesses are required by law to maintain records....
Why You Need a Personal Injury Attorney
Holding a party responsible for your injuries takes more than showing up to court with pictures of an accident scene or promises made by the other party while at the scene. Here is how the legal team at Craig Annin & Baxter can help during this situation:...
Can I Get Alimony?
Ending a marriage is an emotionally and physically draining experience. It can also be financially draining. The divorcing partners must go forward supporting two households on the same pool of income that once supported a single household. Spousal support – called...
Street Racing – Danger for all
It should be common sense that street racing is dangerous. However, many people do not seem to be aware of the dangers of street racing, as they continue to do it. There are many issues that can come up as a result of this, as it is not only the drivers who can be...
Injured in a Boating Accident in New Jersey? What are your rights?
Injured in a Boating Accident in New Jersey? What are your rights? Summertime is right around the corner and many New Jersey residents and visitors cannot wait to get out on the wide array of waterways in and around the state. The Jersey Shore is famous for many...
What Is Considered Reasonable Accommodation At The Workplace?
The Americans With Disabilities Act prohibits people from being discriminated against because they have disabilities. Employers are also required to make accommodations to make it easier for people to do their job. What is a Reasonable Accommodation? A reasonable...
Considering Divorce Mediation? What You Should Know!
Divorce mediation is designed for you and your spouse when your marriage ends. If you find you cannot agree on the details of your divorce, mediation might be the right choice for you. A neutral third party agrees to meet with you both to discuss the items in your...
Timothy E. Annin awarded James J. McLaughlin Award
McLaughlin Award honors go to Linares, Annin and Reek The New Jersey State Bar Association Civil Trial Bar Section recognized three attorneys with the annual James J. McLaughlin Award with a ceremony at The Palace at Somerset Hills in Somerset on Feb. 15. The award...
NON-DISCLOSURE PROVISIONS IN AUTO SALES, LEASING, AND REPAIR CONTRACTS BANNED
NON-DISCLOSURE PROVISIONS IN AUTO SALES, LEASING, AND REPAIR CONTRACTS BANNED A non-disclosure bill, A-4044, passed both houses of the New Jersey Legislature and was signed into law by Governor Christie in a late flurry of legislation before Governor Christie left...