HOW IS THE APPLICATION OF THE “BASEBALL RULE” AFFECTED BY THE EXPANSION OF NETTING IN MAJOR LEAGUE BALLPARKS?
Major League Baseball this past off-season issued a recommendation that all teams lengthen the safety netting at ballparks to increase fan safety. http://m.mlb.com/news/article/159233076/mlb-issues-recommendations-on-netting. Tampa Bay was one of the teams that heeded the new recommendations; “I don’t think we’re taking anything away from the fans who are there,” said Rays vice president of operations/facilities Rick Nafe. “My own personal observation — I have sat in seats in that area that are unprotected by a net, and I tend to enjoy the game a lot more when I know there’s a net in front of me. You know, some of those seats you have to pay attention constantly. That’s just a personal opinion. But I don’t think we’re going to be taking anything away from the fans.” http://m.mlb.com/news/article/159233076/mlb-issues-recommendations-on-netting.
Despite their best intentions, a Rays fan was struck and seriously injured by a baseball fouled by a Rays player that passed through the protective netting and struck her in the face. http://abcnews.go.com/Sports/fan-rays-game-struck-foul-ball-protective-netting/story?id=38442152
Apparently, at the bottom of the seam where the new netting joined the old, triangular gaps were left to provide access to the camera wells. The gaps angled sideways from the field, and the width of the opening facing the field was no more than 6 inches, which made it seemingly unlikely for a ball to get through. http://www.tampabay.com/news/fan-struck-by-foul-ball-is-in-the-hospital-rays-add-netting-to-close-gap/2273551 The Rays have already taken steps to close off those gaps, and the injured fan is recovering from facial injuries that required surgery.
The “Baseball Rule” has long protected baseball teams, as well as hockey teams and other sports from lawsuits for injuries suffered by fans when they are struck by projectiles that leave the field of play or rink. It is a specialized negligence rule that has been in effect since the early twentieth-century. Patrons who chose unprotected seating areas were routinely denied recovery. Such decisions based their decisions on two facts: that the danger of errant balls was common knowledge and that spectators sitting in unscreened seats assumed the risk of injury. See, e.g., Brisson v. Minneapolis Baseball & Athletic Ass’n, 185 Minn. 507, 240 N.W. 903 (1932); Kavafian v. Seattle Baseball Ass’n, 107 Wash. 249, 181 P. 677 (1919). Thus, the rule established a fact-specific standard of care for injuries caused by errant balls at baseball stadiums by accounting for the open and obvious nature of the risk that batted balls pose to fans. Maisonave v. Newark Bears Prof’l Baseball Club, Inc., 185 N.J. 70, 78 (2005).
NEW JERSEY AND THE BASEBALL RULE
In New Jersey and several other states, the operator of a sports venue must provide protected seating “sufficient for those spectators who may be reasonably anticipated to desire protected seats on an ordinary occasion,” and second, the operator must provide protection for spectators in “the most dangerous section” of the stands. The second component of this limited duty may ordinarily be satisfied by the operator providing screened seats behind home plate in baseball and behind the goals in hockey. New Jersey follows a hybrid approach, patrons in the seating areas of a stadium are subject to the limited duty “Baseball Rule”, while those in other areas of the venue are protected by the business invitee rule, which provides that a landowner “owe[s] a duty of reasonable care to guard against any dangerous conditions on his or her property that the owner either knows about or should have discovered.” Maisonave v. Newark Bears Prof’l Baseball Club, Inc., 185 N.J. 70, 85 (2005) Where the operator of a stadium provides screened seats for the members of the public that desire such protection, and the protection fails, is the operator liable for the injuries that result? The answer is determined by the particular facts of the incident. A Florida jury may have to determine whether leaving the triangular gap described in Marc Topkin’s story for the Tampa Bay Times constituted a failure by the Rays to take reasonable care to protect their patrons. If this happened in New Jersey and you were a juror – what would you decide?
Contact CockerillCraigMoore Law
If you have a concern about your legal rights, remedies, and obligations contact the experienced lawyers of Craig Annin & Baxter, LLP.
What is a nuisance under the Commercial Maintenance Code of the City of Woodbury?
Every location has its own laws pertaining to keeping the peace and avoiding nuisances. This includes the City of Woodbury, which has the Commercial Maintenance Code that covers many different points, including defining nuisance. Having this code is important to...
3 winter driving tips
You may experience plenty of cold, snow and ice during the winter in New Jersey. According to U.S. News and World Report, winter driving conditions contribute to 17% of all vehicle crashes. Whenever possible, it is preferable to postpone your trip until conditions...
How do doctors identify and treat internal bleeding?
After a car accident, you worry you may have injuries you cannot see. Learning the signs of internal bleeding could help you build a legal case and understand what treatment you need. WebMD explores internal bleeding symptoms and treatment options. If you suspect you...
Post-exposure prophylaxis
Animal bites are not something victims should take lightly. Even seemingly minor animal bites can quickly turn into a major health issue and possibly a threat to victims’ lives. This is particularly true if the animal in question was rabid. Though the risk of...
What psychological injuries do dog attacks cause children?
If you have a son or daughter, you undoubtedly exercise additional caution when your family is around unfamiliar dogs. After all, according to the American Veterinary Medical Association, more than half of the roughly 800,000 bite victims each year are children....
A look at statistics dealing with fatal crashes in 2021
Several agencies compile information on motor vehicle accidents in New Jersey. While these numbers do not adequately represent the scope of pain and suffering from vehicle crashes, they do provide a window into the toll of accidents. The statistics illustrate that...
How does inattentional blindness impact safety?
When you get behind the wheel and hit the road, it is important to be in peak mental and physical wellness. One wrong move and you could end up in a crash, which could harm you, your passengers, or anyone else outside of your car. But sometimes, distractions will...
How can your clothing help prove injury liability?
Experiencing a fall on someone else’s property may cause you serious pain and keep you from working while you heal your injuries. Unfortunately, the property owner may contest your claims that the owner’s negligence caused your injury. This is why you should consider...
Trucker substance abuse violations increasing
Many New Jersey motorists exercise extra care when driving close to commercial trucks. However, research shows that not all commercial truck drivers are exercising the same level of care. A Drug & Alcohol Clearinghouse that logs trucker alcohol or drug infractions...
How does drowsiness alter driver safety?
Driver safety is one of the biggest concerns many drivers have, as this can affect whether or not they get involved in a crash. The worse overall driver safety is, the higher the chance of an individual crash occurring, which can alter a victim's life. In order to...