WHEN CAN FINANCIAL PENALTIES BE USED TO DETER NON-COMPLIANCE WITH A MARITAL SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT?
20-2-2066 Holtham v. Lucas, N.J. Super. App. Div. (Ostrer, J.) (18 pp.) Plaintiff appealed from the trial court’s order requiring him to pay defendant $150 per day of plaintiff’s non-compliance with a provision of the parties’ marital settlement agreement that required plaintiff to timely pay off the loan of a vehicle equitably distributed to defendant and tender her title to the car. The MSA also imposed a “per diem penalty of $150” for any breach of the agreement. On appeal, plaintiff argued that the $150 per diem charge constituted an unenforceable contractual penalty. The court agreed that, under traditional contract principles, the per diem charge would constitute an unenforceable penalty as contractual damages should be limited to measurable compensable losses. The court noted that contractual penalties were disfavored to avoid oppression, excessive recovery, and deterrence of economically efficient breach. However, the court affirmed the award entered in favor of defendant and against plaintiff. The court ruled that contractual rules disfavoring penalties did not apply with equal force to marital settlement agreements. The court ruled that marital settlement agreements were intended to foster post-divorce stability and thus enforcement of penalty provisions in MSAs could serve that purpose by deterring non-compliance that was not economically motivated and compensating the non-breaching party for the emotional harm that can result from the breach of an agreement that arises from a personal relationship. Specifically, the court noted the trial court’s finding that plaintiff’s breach was deliberate and lacking any reasoned or economic justification. However, the court noted that although penalty provisions in divorce settlement agreements were enforceable, it held that trial courts retained their inherent authority to ensure that penalty provisions were fair and equitable and to modify such provisions to correct any excessiveness or unfairness.
For those in need of help regarding financial penalties, contact Craig Annin & Baxter to discuss your case or schedule a consultation.
When a Victim of a Car Accident Should Talk to an Attorney
If you have been the victim of a car accident we wish you a swift and uncomplicated recovery. Pursue appropriate treatment from your primary care provider and follow their recommendations for treatment and specialists to see. Along with getting medical treatment for...
Municipal Entity Representation: Why They Need Lawyers Too
If you have been elected to a position on a governing body, congratulations and condolences. This may be your first elected position and you may find that the adage, be careful what you wish for, is all too true. Governing a municipality is a challenging undertaking;...
RED FLAG LAWS: WHAT ARE THEY AND DO WE HAVE ONE IN NEW JERSEY?
The national debate about gun control includes the prospect of Congress taking up consideration of expanded background checks and “red flag” laws. You might wonder what a “red flag” law is and how it may apply. New Jersey has a red flag law called the “Extreme Risk...
Contact the Firm of Craig Annin & Baxter for More Info
Boating season is here, and this means good times out on the water. It also brings with it a serious responsibility for your own safety as well as the safety of your family. There are certain precautions that you will need to take in order to stay completely safe out...
SPOUSAL SUPPORT IN NEW JERSEY: WHAT ARE THE REQUIREMENTS?
Spousal support, sometime called alimony, may be ordered in New Jersey divorces in certain situations. An order for spousal support is not guaranteed, so you should consider consulting with the Woodbury family lawyers from Craig Annin & Baxter if you believe...
Splitting the Equity in My Home During a Divorce
Are you planning to divorce your spouse? One of the most important things to keep in mind is that you will need to divide up the equity in your home. Equity can be defined as the difference between the value of your home and the amount of money that you still owe on...
How Long Does a Personal Injury Case Usually Take?
Personal injuries lawsuits are unfortunately common. We say unfortunately because we don’t like the fact that there are people out there who are still getting injured through no fault of their own. Our crowded streets make these events more likely to occur. We...
New Jersey Courts Address Parental Liability for Underage Drinking and Going Forward Imposes Liability on Underage Adults Who Host
On June 6, 2019 the New Jersey Superior Court’s Appellate Division, the intermediate appeals court, decided whether homeowners whose children consume alcohol and allow other underage adults to consume alcoholic beverages at their home are liable for resulting...
A New Jersey state court entered a $27.65 million judgment for UFC
A New Jersey state court entered a $27.65 million judgment for UFC middleweight contender Yoel Romero following a damages trial involving a tainted training supplement that led to a suspension and lost professional opportunities, his legal team said today. Entered by...
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Going Through a Divorce
Going through a divorce is an emotionally taxing time. It can be easy to let emotions get the best of you. Avoid making these serious mistakes to keep your divorce as stress-free and cost-effective as possible. Waiting Too Long to Consult with an Experienced Divorce...